Episode 103: Neil Butcher === Intro Music and Highlighted Quote --- [00:00:05] Neil Butcher: Essentially what we try to do is to build partnerships with individual institutions to develop what we thought were models of good practice, and then try and use those networking relationships to share those more widely as best as we could. I'm under no illusions that we've ever represented Africa and we certainly never purported to do that. I think what we were able to do successfully in the context of broader global conversations is through having built those relationships, it did mean that when, for example, UNESCO or Commonwealth of Learning was planning activities, that we were able to be a source of intelligence regarding suitable people, institutions, organizations, structures, whatever, to be inviting into the global conversations. Podcast Introduction --- [00:00:57] Alan Levine: Hello listeners to episode 103 of OEGlobal Voices, the podcast we produce here at Open Education Global. Each episode we share with you, conversation style, people, practices, and ideas from open educators from around the world. And around the world we go to  Johannesburg, South Africa for our conversation with Neil Butcher, recorded a bit while back on July 1, 2026. I am guilty of falling behind on my podcast editing but these episodes just get better with time. Our reason for talking to Neil is part of our coverage of Open Education Awards for Excellence, and a 2025 Award for Organizational Leadership given by the OEGlobal Board of Directors went to OER Africa, just one of many education initiatives designed and implemented by Neil Butcher & Associates. As it happens, our conversation goes much broader and covers Neil’s two decade career in supporting government and organizational policy and practice development mostly in the Global South. We also recognize that Neil is an active contributor to OEGlobal’s Network of Open Organizations. Neil’s experience and his perspective comes across so clearly and points the way to a sustainable future of opportunity afforded by open education. Let’s get to the conversation. Meet Neil Butcher --- [00:02:24] Alan Levine: Hello Neil, thank you for spending some time with us today. And, the first thing of course is introducing yourself, and what you do and where in the world you are. [00:02:33] Neil Butcher: So where in the world I am is always an entertaining question, but actually at the moment I'm at home, and home is in Johannesburg in South Africa. Just by way of background, I'm an education consultant, I suppose is the technical term that I would use to describe myself, although I don't really like being labeled as a consultant particularly because a lot of consultants don't have a great reputation. But I've worked in the education sector for over thirty years. I began my career at an NGO called South African Institute for Distance Education, or Saide. Saide is now the organization that houses OER Africa. And, I've worked in education policy development, strategic planning, research, monitoring and evaluation, and other associated activities, for over thirty years with a very heavy focus on issues related to educational technology. That's both on the kind of educational front as well as on the data and management information systems front, where I've done a lot of work. I've been very privileged in my life, I think by this stage to have worked in about, I think at the last count, somewhere fifty or sixty different countries around the world. My work is exclusively in the developing world. I've worked right across Africa, in many countries as well as in South Asia, the Pacific, Eastern Europe, the Caribbean and elsewhere as well. At the moment I'm actually quite heavily engaged in activities in the Caribbean, working with ministries of education there. So yeah, I've had a long and entertaining career. I'm not sure if I've made any difference along the way, but it's certainly been an interesting journey. And, as I say, I felt very privileged to have had the opportunities to travel in the way that I have and to have participated in a number of really exciting educational activities. Early OER Vision --- [00:04:34] Neil Butcher: So maybe just to add to that from the perspective of an OEGlobal conversation, I'd say that my interest in the concept of Open Educational Resources actually predates the existence of the term OER by some time. I started working quite early in my career with the Department of Education here in South Africa on developing educational technology strategies and policies for the government. And way back then, before the concepts of open licensing even existed, it seemed to me logical that governments should try and take ownership of and manage the IP of the educational materials that they were making available in school systems. And that investing in that way would potentially lead to the creation of higher quality teaching and learning materials than you were leaving that to market forces, as well as allowing for diversification, of the kinds of materials we create. And particularly in those days, which is the very early days of the Internet, would allow for the creation of a lot of computer-based multimedia video and audio material that actually just wasn't available in the marketplace. And that obviously, once you've made that investment as a government, you can then leverage it multiple times over, share it with others, reuse, adapt, and all those things that we now associate with the concept of Open Educational Resources. So I'll say that I'm pretty passionate about those concepts, but absolutely at the center for me was always the idea that they should be underpinning a process of educational transformation, and we shouldn't be using those ideas just to replicate schooling systems that we know fail. In fact, the more I've worked and the more countries I've worked in, the more convinced I am that school systems are dysfunctional effectively. That doesn't mean students don't get a lot of value out of them. but I do think that they can be much, much better. And so for me, always the concept of OER centrally is about pedagogical transformation and not about financial efficiency. So sorry, that's a long-winded answer to your question, but it also does explain some of how we got to the point of starting OER Africa some years ago. [00:06:46] Alan Levine: We'll get there. We'll get there. You've given me a lot to cover. My thinking is just asking to talk about, a continent of Africa is huge, but obviously your work is much farther beyond that. But, just for our audience's sake, because they're listening just to the sound and you said you're working at home, I always ask guests if they can describe their environment right now. What do you see around the room that you're in? [00:07:08] Neil Butcher: I see a room that's in transition, because, my youngest son has started his university career down at the University of Cape Town, which is 1,400 kilometers from here. So I'm in the process of starting as an empty nester to reimagine my personal space, and so I'm turning my office into what I hope will become more of a kind of Zen-like study environment. So that's why you see on the one hand behind me a backdrop of a wonderful, peaceful wallpaper mural, and then on the other hand you still see pictures of The Magnificent Seven and the Blues Brothers. And I've got David Bowie album covers in front of me here. We're busy transitioning the office into more of a study space that I hope over time will allow me to be not only working but also using my time to be a bit more contemplative and more creative, I hope, the things that I'll be able to do over the next few years. That's what the office space looks like currently. [00:08:09] Alan Levine: Thank you. it's a little bit of a thing I just enjoy because people make deliberate choices for their space around them. And I was noticing your pictures on the wall, but we, won't get too distracted with that. [00:08:20] Neil Butcher: As I say, I'm halfway through the choices. I'm still one foot in the old world and one foot in the new world [00:08:27] Alan Levine: It's a good place. Schooling Reflections --- [00:08:28] Alan Levine: Where did you spend your childhood years? And, as a young student, what did you think of school? [00:08:34] Neil Butcher: I'm born and bred in Johannesburg, in South Africa. So I grew up here. I've always lived here. I went to a private boarding school, just up the road in a- another town called Pretoria, which is about a thirty-minute drive from Johannesburg. I was a weekly boarder there. I'd say to answer your question about schooling, to be honest, I didn't really apply my mind to it very much other than that obviously as a young child, I really wasn't particularly enamored with the idea of having to be in classes all day. At an all-boys school, certainly growing up in the '80s, you didn't get a lot of credibility by following the rules and doing what you were told. So we always considered the systems and structures of schooling to be a little bit silly, so we tried to do as little as we possibly could, as far as the official requirements were concerned and got up to as much mischief as we possibly could. I feel like that was a lot easier in the old days than it is now. I think actually increasingly, if I compare my children, I've got two sons, and if I compare their schooling with mine, it was a significantly more structured and rigid experience, I think, than we had. And I think that's partly because, in the intervening thirty or so years, I think there has been a drift towards greater standardization and definition of the curriculum at a central level. And I think that's reduced the agency of teachers, and given them reduced control over what they can do with students and how to create, interesting and engaging learning environments. But I think there's also just a huge amount of pressure and particularly this is more on the kind of, top-end schooling, front for students whose parents are wealthier and can afford, better quality schooling. I think there's just this relentless drive that kind of says that doing more means better education, and so that's taking more subjects, doing more extracurricular activities, being involved in more sporting activities, and almost feeling under pressure to be building a CV for yourself even, in the last four or five years of your school career, which I honestly think is very sad. I think it's taken away significant aspects of what it means to be growing up, as a human being, and of childhood that I think is very unfortunate. I spent a considerable portion of my time as a father trying to persuade my children to do as little as they could possibly get away with doing, by, for example, identifying-- once they'd identified what they wanted to study at university, I encouraged them to work out exactly how many points they need and then game the examination system so that they didn't get more points than they needed, 'cause that was just gonna be a waste of their time and effort. I'm being facetious at one level, but there is a serious point in there that I do think that actually, particularly schooling systems, I think in that growing rigidity and pressure that that's being put on children, I actually think it's counterproductive. And in fact, as I travel around the world increasingly, I think that we can now happily just describe that as a form of child abuse. And it's often much more explicit and worse when you start also looking at less well-resourced schools, where actually I think the abusive nature of that is actually more explicit. But I think even in top-end private schools where one assumes that the experience is in the child's best interests, I'm not convinced that's true. And I think the relentless push for examinations and the messaging that you will fail in life if you don't do all these things is really very damaging. And I think we had much less of it growing up is, my key point. I'm sounding like an old man now obviously, but... [00:12:31] Alan Levine: A man with much experience, which is a good thing. Our reason for being here, we'll talk about last year, OEGlobal gave OER Africa an award distributed by our board for leadership of organization. And you already mentioned that you were already doing work in the government with educational technology and distance education. So when did you first hear the word "open education" and then was the reaction of "I'm already doing this?" Or what was the door opening to open education as a thing? [00:13:05] Neil Butcher: Seeing as you're asking me the questions, you have to blame yourself for getting bored by the response. Origins of Open Learning --- [00:13:11] Neil Butcher: Practically speaking, I came across the concept of open learning as I started my career in this would be like nineteen ninety-one, ninety-two. In that context it was being used, in relation to the concept of distance education. So back in those days, distance education was predominantly a print-based phenomenon where-- because obviously, the Internet had only just been in-- well it hadn't just been invented, but it was only becoming, publicly accessible around that time. I started my career working on WordPerfect 3.1, even before W-Windows, 3.1 existed. We're going back quite a long time before technology had mainstreamed. In those days, distance education was really about designing courses that were print-based, sending those print-based materials to students who would work their way through them, submit assignments, complete their studies. And particularly the Open University in the United Kingdom and other large universities had started in the sort of late nineteen sixties and early nineteen seventies to conceptualize this and actually label it as open learning. So I spent the formative part of my time at Saide trying to get conceptual clarity about the distinction between distance education and open learning, and understanding open learning actually as a kind of core set of key principles that you could in fact actually apply to any mode of education, whether it was distance or face-to-face or a hybrid of the two. Obviously even in those days, all good distance education would include some form of face-to-face contact with students. The Open University in the United Kingdom, for example, was world-renowned in a way for having its distributed decentralized tutoring systems to provide face-to-face interaction with students from time to time. We have a very big distance education institution in South Africa, which is called the University of South Africa, and Saide was actually established by the ANC Education desk just ahead of the end of apartheid to try to get its head around the transformation of UNISA as a structure-- UNISA was in those days, one of the kind of key apartheid institutions. The South African Broadcasting Corporation was another, and there were several others. And so Saide was very involved in thinking about the transformation of UNISA and the SABC as far as educational broadcasting was concerned. I was very fortunate to be involved in all of that. I'm mentioning all of that because actually those principles of open learning that kind of became part of my professional DNA during those early years working at Saide actually had no relationship to ICT or technology or open licensing at all. They were really about principles of good educational practice. We developed quite a lot of concept papers around the concept of open learning, and then a lot of that found its way into policies of the government. What I was trying to articulate in that conceptual work was the idea that, that open learning as a set of principles is actually about trying to find the appropriate balance between often opposing forces in the design of education systems. Open learning was never seen for me as an achievable concept that you can say, "Now we're doing open learning." But, if you're designing education systems and then institutions, programs and courses, using the principles of open learning, it provides you a kind of conceptual framework to look at the trade-offs that you have to make. If we're increasing access in terms of numbers of students who can get into the system, that might have implications in terms of finances, and the quality of the student support or administration that we can provide. So getting the balance between access, equity, quality, cost-effectiveness was all a critical part of how we thought about open learning at the time. That predates, I think, the UNESCO claims credit for coining the term OER, I think back in 2002. I was already working very closely with UNESCO in those days. So I'd say that I heard about that term as soon as it was coined because I was part of those processes and discussions in some form. I also did a lot of work with UNESCO and the Commonwealth of Learning helping to shape and define what we mean by open educational resources. Defining OER and OEP --- [00:17:40] Neil Butcher: The one thing I tried to emphasize building on that history was that we should actually treat the concept of open educational resources primarily as a legal concept. Which is to say that, what it's really about is the application of a licensing framework that gives permissions to people to do things with those resources that they would ordinarily not be able to do under all rights reserved copyright. I've fought very hard and unsuccessfully to try to limit the definition of OER to that legal concept because my view was then, and still is now, that when you start infusing the concept with a whole lot of qualitative definitions, that sort of say, "Oh, OER is good in this way and that way," and so on, y-you're actually making a false correlation between the fact that we've applied a license. That doesn't necessarily mean that's achieving the qualitative goals that we would like to achieve through the application of that licensing. That has to be done purposefully, and it needs to be systematically planned and implemented if we want to achieve those qualitative goals. As I say, I failed. And, I do think what facilitated that failure, unfortunately, was then the introduction by another group of people of the concept of Open Education Practices. And many of the people who did that I had long discussions and collegial and friendly arguments with them about this, is that what they were doing was introducing a concept of open education that superficially looked very similar to what we had been developing around the concept of open learning prior to the digitization of content. But then when you looked in practice, effectively what they were saying is that open educational practices are about using OERs. I actually think that robbed the whole concept of open learning of its power, and it also actually robbed the concept of OER of its transformative potential because it conflated two things and we weren't using those concepts systematically and defining them clearly. Once you've created that type of confusion, my experience is that then people find it impossible to see that transformative potential. Sadly we're seeing very similar, practices underway with AI because, people are using artificial intelligence as a composite term to refer to what is actually ten, fifteen, twenty different practices, technologies, tools that have very different educational applications and utility that can be better or worse under different circumstances. And to lump them all together and talk about their transformative potential as if it's one thing actually removes the potential for transformation. Once you've done that, in my experience, then what we're gonna end up doing, whether it's with the concept of Open Education Practices or the concept of OER or AI or EdTech or whatever else you like, in robbing them of their transformative potential, we're gonna see that they end up being used to reinforce the models of education that we already have rather than transforming them. I've seen that happen five or six times over with various iterations of educational technology. I have no reason to suspect currently that the hype around AI is taking us down a different pathway despite everyone's claim that it is. [00:21:06] Alan Levine: I'm with you there, and we'll get, back to that. But first of all, let's dial it back. Why OER Africa Started --- [00:21:11] Alan Levine: OER Africa as an organization, what was the reason? Who was behind that? And what was your goal at the time to create an organization like that? [00:21:22] Neil Butcher: To be clear, OER Africa is actually not an organization. it's an initiative. So the organization is Saide, which is my former employer, Saide-- it doesn't actually call itself South African Institute for Distance Education anymore because its mandate is much wider than distance education. But OER Africa has been an initiative of Saide for a long term. I think really the origin of was to the extent that I can remember it, 'cause it, it's going back some time, was actually in conversations with The Hewlett Foundation, particularly with Cathy Casserly at the time, because the Hewlett Foundation obviously was very early on a kind of leading, donor agency supporting the development of OER. Their collaboration with and investment in the MIT OpenCourseWare repository was in many ways, the single app initiative that brought the concept of OER into the mainstream, so to speak. I was fortunate as a consequence of my engagements with UNESCO, Commonwealth of Learning and others to be around those conversations and so began conversations with Cathy Casserly at the time, making sure that this concept was not something that was the preserve of the developed world, but that we actually started also, activities that might help the developing world also to see the potential to develop people's knowledge and understanding of the concept of OER, and make sure that African institutions and governments were at the table and participating in those conversations. At certain levels and we always knew this, it's very grandiose to say OER Africa, when you're gonna base yourself in an initiative in a small NGO based in South Africa. We were always very explicit about that and acknowledged the limitations of what we were able to achieve. We faced, first of all, a linguistic problem. Africa is a linguistically incredibly diverse continent. Unfortunately, it's also still to a significant extent, defined linguistically by its colonial past. What that meant practically is that most of our work tended to be in what's called Anglophone Africa. I think that's a terrible post-colonial misnomer because Anglophone Africa is really an incredibly linguistically diverse set of places. And English is only one language of many languages. That meant that we worked much less in what's called Francophone Africa, and also in the smaller context of Lusophone Africa, which is obviously those countries that had a, a Portuguese colonial past. And we'd never really worked at all beyond sub-Saharan Africa. We'd never worked at all really in North Africa. We also took a decision very early on that we would focus on higher education in OER Africa, which is still predominantly where we focus our attention as an initiative. These are at a certain level simply pragmatic choices where you know, one can't do everything. So when OER Africa was conceptualized, we defined those kinds of limitations, and said that what we would try to do is to build partnerships with African universities and African agencies. That's included historically, for example, the Association of African Universities we've worked with in the past, the Association for the Development of Education in Africa. We have a very strong current relationship with the African Librarians Association. And we've also worked with several of the regional structures like the Southern African Development Community and its equivalent structures in East and West Africa. That tended to fluctuate up and down over time according to resource availability. Amplifying African Voices --- [00:25:11] Neil Butcher: But, essentially what we try to do is to build partnerships with individual institutions to develop what we thought were models of good practice, and then try and use those networking relationships to share those more widely as best as we could. I'm under no illusions that we've ever represented Africa and we certainly never purported to do that. I hope that's very clear. I think what we were able to do successfully in the context of broader global conversations is through having built those relationships, it did mean that when, for example, UNESCO or Commonwealth of Learning was planning activities, that we were able to be a source of intelligence regarding suitable people, institutions, organizations, structures, whatever, to be inviting into the global conversations. I do feel like we were successful in ensuring that African voices were at least at the table and hopefully sometimes being heard. That's an ongoing challenge, and a worsening challenge at the moment because the world is increasingly retreating into isolationism. At some levels, the spaces for conversations are diminishing for now. I'm sure they'll return, once we have to go through some rounds of geopolitical madness from time to time as a world, and hopefully when that all settles down, I think we'll, get back into those conversations. It's also complicated bringing African voices into global conversations, partly because of resource disparities. There is a simple reality. [I'm] always entertained by American counterparts and colleagues who come and sit in a conversation with their African counterparts and say, "Ooh, these problems are so similar to what we deal with at home." And I'm like, then you're clearly not listening hard enough. The resource discrepancies between what's happening in, say, a university in, Uganda or Kenya compared to a Canadian or American university is just so significant in terms of human resources, financial capacity, and so on. To try and talk as if the problems are the same,-- I understand why people say that and, obviously there are common themes, but I think that, there's been that challenge in terms of resource discrepancy. And then there's also the challenge that, unfortunately part of the post-colonial inheritance is unfortunately that the African countries and individuals have been told for such a long time that their voice doesn't matter, and that they are not equal. Unfortunately at some levels it's very hard not to internalize that, even if consciously you don't believe that. I think people often come to the table feeling as if they don't have equal rights for their voice to be heard, and often lacking the confidence to share the good practices. I'm making massive generalizations in what I'm saying here. But, we've tried our hardest to make sure , at least some perspectives, from the African context and from the developing world are always on the table in the conversations. Hopefully we've built up relationships with other organizations and institutions so that can happen more systematically. [00:28:40] Alan Levine: I'm glad you make a disclaimer you don't represent all of Africa, which seems like, where else in the world do we talk about open education at a continental scale? As you've clearly stated, there's too much to take in, but I think also, making a case you can't define an African perspective, but it's definitely different, and influence than North American. Can we just talk about, in, in the very beginnings, I'd imagine, the focus was on access to resources and content being OER. What were some of the first things that OER Africa did in those early years? Early OER Africa Work --- [00:29:20] Neil Butcher: Well, a lot of the early days was advocacy work just to introduce people to the concept of Open Educational resources. That's often trickier than it should be, because the concept of open licensing is quite a difficult thing to explain to people who aren't steeped in copyright issues. I'm a great fan of the Creative Commons licensing framework, and I think it's an incredibly flexible and relevant tool, and it's what we use all the time and what we encourage everyone to use. But, it doesn't lend itself to easy explanation and easy application. So just trying to explain to people what open licensing is, why it can be beneficial to use open licenses, when making investments in educational materials, what the benefits of investing in OERs might be. It's also more complicated in many of the contexts in which I've worked compared to, say, the United States or Europe, because in the United States and Europe, the financial incentive for investing in open licensing, I think is much easier to make. If you're looking at many African contexts, it's not like people are paying a lot of money for teaching and learning materials. if you look at the Indian textbook system, for example, the cost of textbooks is so cheap already that you're actually not gonna achieve great financial efficiencies by investing in open licensing. Obviously, that's a little bit different at the university level, but also more complicated at the university level because at the school level, if you're investing in open equivalents of textbooks, the scale is what gives you the financial efficiency. Whereas very often the expensive proprietary textbooks or resources that you'd be seeking to displace from a financial perspective at a university level are not being used in large enough numbers to get you to that economy of scale that would warrant the investment in openly licensed materials. We always grappled with the reality that advocacy challenge, trying to persuade people about the use of open licensing and OERs, is actually quite a complicated thing to do. So we spent a lot of time working with institutions, with various of those other networks and agencies trying to get that messaging right, just trying to raise the profile of OER. And then also working with individual institutions to try and showcase what the potential was in practice. There was always one example that I loved from early days. Health Network Success --- [00:32:01] Neil Butcher: We created a little, health network, which was a collaboration between two Ghanaian institutions, two South African institutions, and the University of Michigan, under faculties of medicine. And at that stage, Michigan had received funding from the Hewlett Foundation for some of its OER work. What we wanted to do was to then start introducing these other four institutions, which was University of Cape Town, University of the Western Cape, University of Ghana, and the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, those latter two from Ghana. We built this kind of collaboration between those five universities and ourselves, started introducing faculties of medicine, in the four African institutions, the concept of OER and getting them to use it. And at that stage, I think actually the intent was, to imagine that through this process of open licensing, the African universities would be able to gain access to a whole lot of the IP that was being created at the University of Michigan, which obviously is a world-renowned, medical faculty. But in fact, what happened is someone from the University of Michigan went and did a sabbatical in Ghana. He started working with the faculty there. They realized that one of the significant problems that they faced, as a faculty is that very often when the students are going into the hospital environment to do the rounds, there's so many students going into individual and under-resourced hospital environments. Very often many students are sitting at the back of that space, can't actually see the patient. So when the lecturer or the doctor is talking about this tropical disease or whatever it is that person has, actually a lot of the students can't hear what she or he is saying. They can't see the students. They're not really getting the benefit that you would expect from that practical activity of going and doing the rounds in the university hospital, which is what you would expect as part of a medical student's career. So what they started doing was filming some of those processes, obviously with the consent of the patients and whatever else. And as they started doing that, what they started realizing is that all the real expertise around tropical diseases is not sitting in the University of Michigan or anywhere else where they don't have tropical diseases, but is obviously sitting in the heads of the academics, in places like Kumasi, which is where KNUST is based and where this colleague of ours was working. They actually started filming a whole lot of things. The one that I just remember is around something called the Buruli ulcer, which is not entertaining video material if you're not a doctor-- might not be even entertaining if you are a doctor, depending on what you like watching. But they were able to actually film this and start structuring a lot of the knowledge around these tropical diseases that in fact was not being captured anywhere else. And then by sharing it under open licenses, in fact, the first instances of reuse of openly licensed material in that health network happened because the African experts had captured this information, and then the colleagues from University of Michigan were able to use it back in Michigan to teach about tropical diseases. This also then had the knock-on benefit that it raised the profile of those African academics. They started getting invited to conferences as tropical disease experts and and just had a whole lot of very positive consequences for everybody. That example, which I just happened to remember well, is just one example where we were able to really showcase the real power of open licensing in that it was capturing knowledge that otherwise was not being captured, making it accessible in formats that it could be reused by others to the benefit of everyone. And it wasn't detracting from the opportunities for those African academics who were capturing their knowledge because it was actually raising their academic profile and enabling them then to actually further their career and gain recognition for the real expertise that they had as tropical disease specialists, which before they had not been getting recognized for. For me that example really illustrates perfectly just what the potential and power of OER is. The unfortunate problem is still, and this is where we kept getting tripped up a lot is - a lot of people just have some really strange ideas about intellectual property and the importance of hanging on to things and protecting it. I've always found that very sad, not more than anything else, because in my experience, predominantly the people who have that type of mindset around closure and protection is they actually close off their own access to opportunities, rather than closing off other people's possibility of exploiting their IP. I think particularly, say, in education, where the economic value of most IP tends towards zero in many respects. I'm not saying all of it, so, please be clear, but a lot of it. And actually, there's a lot more to be gained from sharing your knowledge and putting yourself out and then building the opportunities that flow from that. Certainly, that's been the basis of my entire career is operating in that mode. And I've just found that's accelerated opportunity acquisition rather than denying it. But unfortunately, especially universities, despite their claim to be at the vanguard of the knowledge economy, I find universities predominantly to be made up of very conservative, traditionally-minded people, who don't really understand an enormous amount about what the knowledge economy looks like and how you can really make information work very powerfully. So, a lot of people, again, I'm obviously generalizing, but a lot of people are, very concerned about protection and control, keeping things to themselves. For me, that's not really in the spirit of the university mandate, as it were. Back to your question. That's what we spent a lot of time doing initially, and then trying to develop guides and resources that would help people, to first see that potential and benefit and then once they'd seen it, to start looking at how they could successfully operationalize those activities. [00:38:17] Alan Levine: You really hit on something that I resonate with that in general you get more by sharing than by hoarding. So your, phrasing of it was accurate. And, also you have an uncanny knack for anticipating my questions by talking about that very specific example of remembering what the condition was. I was gonna ask you about a favorite example, so we have that covered there now. [00:38:42] Neil Butcher: If you don't mind, I'll give a completely unrelated example quickly. [00:38:45] Alan Levine: I'd love that. [00:38:45] Neil Butcher: I think showcasing those examples, anecdotally, I think is helpful, but I also kind of limited utility, at a certain point. Scaling with EMIS Hub --- [00:38:55] Neil Butcher: For me, one of the really interesting things is about how we're gonna do this sustainably and scale it successfully. One of the areas where I feel like I've started having much greater success, I mentioned earlier that I've been doing quite a lot of work in the Caribbean, and there - I've actually been providing technical assistance to governments on Education Management Information Systems. These are the national systems that are supposed to be keeping data and records on schools and teachers and students. This is quite central to ministries of education generally in terms of having access to good information. It's extraordinary to discover how many countries don't actually yet have properly functional EMIS systems running. But the other thing that's even more surprising to me is that development agencies and partners have invested multiples of millions of dollars in supporting the development of Education Management Information Systems in countries around the world. I started doing this work actually back in 1994 when I was still in the early days of my career when we actually developed an EMIS for South Africa and then a accompanying school management system that would feed the data from the school level up to the national level. That was very early use of ICT for management information purposes and still runs successfully today, The thing that amazed me is that despite all the money that's been spent on trying to help countries to develop these systems, when I went online again, getting called back into this work in the Caribbean, in a more sustained way and started looking around, I was astonished by how little practical, detailed information there is online about EMIS implementation. So there's a lot of high-level guides, there's a lot of research reports, there's a lot of, you know, statements if successfully implement an EMIS, you need this and this. But practically, there was very little accessible. And, so one of the things that we've been working on over the last two years is to create what we then called the EMIS Hub. When we worked with governments, we made sure that we took the results of that work. So when we developed a policy for a government or a three-year implementation plan, or when we sat with groups of stakeholders and consulted them on what all the functional requirements of the EMIS needed to be, we distill those down into documents and actually share that information, afterwards. We've created this thing called the EMIS Hub, which now actually consolidates all of that and in fact, has, for example, a two hundred-page open data standard that defines what, in this case, all the OECS or Eastern Caribbean State countries, what they would include in their EMIS in terms of data standards and how the data structures need to be constructed and making sure that there's gonna be consistency across all of them. All of that information, which is now actually being used in the terms of reference to procure service providers, so it's actually serving a very specific practical purpose at the government level, is also now accessible under open licenses. I would really like, the next phase of my career, and I think it's one of the things we need to get right with OER and OER sustainability is to actually do something similar-- is, to say, "Let's distill all this information down and actually make it accessible and shareable so that we're not wasting all of this money." I'm just shocked by how much money is being spent on EMIS implementation. Basically doing the same things over and over again because there hasn't been a commitment to sharing all of that knowledge openly and explicitly. This is not a financial issue. It didn't cost me any more money to produce things this way. It just required an intent to make sure that the sharing happened as the last step of the process and then to keep re-sharing. In fact, what I've done with all of that is we've been able to significantly reduce the cost of activities in individual countries because we're building on what's happened in prior countries. We're not actually starting from scratch. So I'm doing policy development, for example, at the moment in Dominica and Grenada, and that's building on policy development that I'd done prior to that in Saint Lucia and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Barbados, Jamaica and other countries. Each time we're doing that, we're actually bringing the cost of actually developing the policies down and making sure that the resulting instrument is covering all the bases, as it were. So you're getting the double benefit. And I really hope that in the next phase. And we know that the Hewlett Foundation is winding up its grant-making activities in the open education space. I've been a great beneficiary of that, and been very grateful always for the funding that I've received from the Hewlett Foundation. But I've always recognized that it's a privilege and that it would come to an end at some point or another. I think for all of us in the open community, it provides us the opportunity to say, " Let's not be sad about that. Let's celebrate what the Hewlett Foundation did." Let's say now how are we gonna take all of that knowledge that we've gained and make sure that we take it to the next level? For me, that EMIS Hub is an example of how we can create knowledge bases that move us to the next level because we're no longer able to depend on the charity of development agencies. Now we have to make sure that it works and that it becomes sustainable with the direct clients, which are the governments and institutions that ought to be benefiting from this. So that's what I really hope will happen in the next phase of our lives as OER Africa. [00:44:38] Alan Levine: You've done a perfect job again. Earlier you spoke your perspective on AI, and you talked about your future and what you wanna do. Personal Passions --- [00:44:44] Alan Levine: So I'm gonna close with, my last question, which has nothing to do with OER Africa. What are your interests and passions, the things that you like to keep busy outside of this work? And you've hinted at some of that already, but let us know what sustains you to on your own time. [00:45:04] Neil Butcher: They keep changing. So one of my passions has always been endurance activities of various kinds. So right at the moment, that happens to be in the form of swimming. I'm preparing for a thirty-three kilometer swim that a friend of mine and I are gonna do from the Greek island of Skopelos in September. So that keeps me out of mischief from time to time, obviously. Earlier on, you asked me about my office, and I talked about the office transforming into a kind of study space. One of the things that are the intersection between professional and personal interest for me is a greater process of engagement around what I'm currently calling "concept of professional freedom." And, wanting to play in the next phase of my life, not just professionally, but, overall, to play a greater role in helping people to think through what that means in practice for them. In the kind of self-help space, we see that there's a lot of discussion about how people can liberate themselves and work through their trauma and all sorts of other kinds of things. We still see the world in very binary terms of seeing that there's our professional life here and our personal life here. When people are trying to focus on self-improvement, they tend to focus on the personal space and assume that the professional space is just something that then happens along the side. And one of the consequences of that I've observed through the work that I've been able to do in governments, in institutions, with teachers and so on, is that you see that people actually have almost defeated themselves in terms of what they want to achieve professionally before they get going because they perceive the world through all of the constraints of the external environment in which they find themselves. Instead of understanding that inside themselves is all the capability that they need and that those constraints actually melt away once you start embracing your own sense of what your professional freedom and purpose needs look like, and that's not actually a career thing. It's actually about you as a human being. It's about your overall transformation. For me personally, it's about the reason why we're having human experiences on earth for ninety-odd or however many years it ends up being while you're alive. And I find that really energizing. I find having those conversations really energizing. I also feel very strongly that those conversations are in fact essential. Many of the government officials I work with, until we're having those conversations together, the idea that OER will be successfully and sustainably implemented is actually never gonna happen. Because we're engaging with people who have been so disempowered in their lives and who have lived that disempowerment. They live it every day in the way in which they approach their work. And therefore, the idea that they will be the agents who drive the transformation is contradictory. But inside them is that capability. And once you start having conversations of that kind with people, it's amazing to see what transformation happens and what becomes possible. So that's something that's always interested me personally in terms of my own personal transformation and my own experiences. And I'm really very keen to make sure that becomes a much more significant part of my overall life experience over the next, say, twenty or so years now that my kids are successfully dispatched off to university to do their own thing. [00:48:33] Alan Levine: I can't thank you enough, Neil. I've gotten so much out of this, and I know our listeners will as well, and I appreciate you taking your time and your mind-reading capability to know what I am going to ask next. I just appreciate all the inspirational work and the way you approach it. Thank you, Neil [00:48:50] Neil Butcher: No, it's a great pleasure. Thank you so much for allowing me the opportunity to share all of the craziness going on in my head. Closing Credits --- [00:48:56] Alan Levine: Wow, what a stream of inspiration we just heard from Neil Butcher. Thank you for listening to this episode of OE Global Voices, the podcast from Open Education Global. Each episode features a different musical intro track selected from the Free Music Archive. For this conversation with Neil Butcher, I selected a track called Not Enough Africa by Ego Response Technician licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License. As all our episodes, this podcast is edited by one human, Alan Levine, assisted by the Descript audio editor which transcribes the audio and allows editing from that text. To be open, this episode was edited at a local coffee shop so the introduction and this closing I usually recorded were generated in Descript from text from my voice it was trained on. You can find this episode at our site voices.oeglobal.org and join followup discussions in our OEG Connect or wherever you interact with us in social media. Look forward to episode 104 coming out soon, featuringOEGlobal Board member Glenda Cox. If you are listening and would like to share your open education work or suggest a future guest, please let us know via our web site or email to voices@oeglobal.org